Coldwater Creek: Rise and Collapse of a Women's Nature Catalog

Coldwater Creek: a catalog that sold Sandpoint by the page

In May 1997, a raffia purse sold for $27.95 in the Coldwater Creek catalog. The same catalog described its home town of Sandpoint, Idaho, as a place where "wildlife still thankfully outnumber the traffic lights." The company worked in a corner of mail order "where romantic prose and hefty price tags meet middle-class affluence."

Dennis and Ann Pence moved to Sandpoint from New York City in 1983. Dennis Pence said they chose the town for lifestyle, not business. They started with $40,000 in savings and got through the first two years on credit cards and pawned possessions. The company was founded in 1984 as a catalog-based marketer. It ran out of a small Sandpoint apartment with a single telephone line and sold nature items such as binoculars and birdfeeders. Customer records were written by hand on 3x5 index cards.

That business reached $1.15 billion in net sales in fiscal 2007. In April 2014 it filed for Chapter 11 and went out of business. The brand outlived the company. On Nov. 2, 2026, Nexus Capital Management completed its purchase of CW Holdings, the parent of Coldwater Creek and Soft Surroundings, from Newtimes Group.

Coldwater Creek

Sells women's clothing, including tunics, pull-on pants, jeans, and dresses, in Misses, Petites, and Women's Plus sizes XS-3X.

Visit Coldwater Creek →

1984–1999: from a black-and-white brochure to Northcountry

The first catalog was a brochure offering 18 items, printed in black and white by the local newspaper. Northcountry, the company's first four-color catalog, came out in 1985. The business posted a profit from 1986 on. Northcountry was still the company's core line in 2001.

Coldwater Creek commissioned original photography and artwork for its covers. Inside, photographs of rivers and mountains ran beside photographs of the merchandise. The catalog used no models, so the reader would not be distracted by how the clothes looked on ideal bodies. The captions were written in purple prose. Each catalog was planned as one illustrated narrative, built to take the reader to a favorite place.

Ann Pence had worked as an advertising copy director at Macy's. In 2001 the company still described its method as "spirited merchandise narratives" with thematic and seasonal photographs. It called its catalogs its most efficient and effective medium for building brand recognition.

The Spirit of the West line launched in 1993. Coldwater Creek made the Inc. 500 four years in a row, from 1992 to 1995. In 1995 it opened its first retail store in Sandpoint by leasing the entire Cedar Street Bridge, a covered bridge in downtown Sandpoint that had been turned into a shopping mall. In the fall of 1996, its advertisements ran in Smithsonian Magazine and The New Yorker.

In January 1997 the company sold 2.5 million shares at $15 each, and the Pences kept 75% of the company. One goal of the sale was to make Coldwater Creek a national brand name like L.L. Bean. By May 1997 the company mailed up to 4 million catalogs, reported 1.1 million active customers and employed 864 people. Sales had climbed to $143 million in the previous year. The average order rose from $91 in 1995 to $133 in 1996.

Dennis Pence described the ideal customer as a woman who lives in San Diego, drives a Volvo and is an attorney. By 2001 the company's stated target was women aged 35 to 55 with household incomes over $50,000. Its men's apparel catalog, Milepost Four, was put up for sale through a broker.

2000–2014: the stores take over

In the fiscal year that ended March 3, 2001, Coldwater Creek mailed 183.6 million catalogs containing 14.4 billion pages. Net sales that year were $458.4 million. The direct channel made up 93.1% of adjusted net sales, down from 96.6% the year before. E-commerce alone brought in $112.9 million, or 24.6% of net sales. The full line had gone online in July 1999.

The first full-line store opened in November 1999. By that fiscal year-end there were ten, and they brought in $31.8 million. They were designed to keep "the Coldwater Creek ambience of soft woods, natural lighting and soothing waterfalls." The company ended 2004 with 114 full-line stores, and retail sales were by then half of total revenue.

Fiscal 2007 ended on February 2, 2008. Retail sales rose to $775.1 million from $664.2 million, while direct sales slipped to $376.4 million from $390.4 million. Net sales reached $1.15 billion, up from $1.05 billion. Even so, the year ended in a $2.5 million net loss, after $55.4 million of net income in fiscal 2006. The store count stood at 306. Comparable store sales (sales at existing stores) fell 19.2% in the fourth quarter.

Chief executive Daniel Griesemer said the company was "clearly not satisfied" with its performance. For fiscal 2008 it planned to spend about $10 million on national brand advertising, down from about $30 million in fiscal 2007. It planned to mail about 104 million catalogs, down from about 129 million. It still planned about 50 store openings in 2008. Its company description at the time still listed direct-mail catalogs beside the stores and the website.

In fiscal 2012, which ended February 2, 2013, net sales were $742.5 million, down from $773.0 million. Retail brought in $574.4 million and the direct segment $168.0 million. The net loss was $81.8 million, following a $99.7 million loss in fiscal 2011. The company ended the year with 349 premium retail stores and a $65.0 million term loan from an affiliate of Golden Gate Capital. It mailed about 55.6 million catalogs, down from about 58.8 million the year before. Under chief executive Jill Dean, the company description named stores, online and mobile applications as its sales channels. Catalogs were left off that list even though the company was still mailing them.

Same-store sales fell 16.8% in the quarter that ended Nov. 2, 2013. On April 11, 2014, Coldwater Creek filed for Chapter 11. It planned to go out of business after asking more than 75 parties for proposals and finding no buyer. At the filing it had 365 stores, about 6,000 employees, assets of $278.5 million and liabilities of $361.3 million. Going-out-of-business sales were set for early May, before the Mother's Day weekend, and shareholders were expected to receive nothing. The company shut its direct mail and online channels, sold off its inventory and laid off the 339 remaining workers at its Sandpoint headquarters.

After 2014: three owners, and the catalog still in the box

Sycamore Partners bought Coldwater Creek's intellectual property and relaunched it as a mail-order and internet retailer only. Headquarters moved to Massachusetts. The company then opened 13 new retail stores between April 2018 and February 2020.

On July 20, 2020, Coldwater Creek posted a goodbye notice and closed its stores and its website at the same time, citing "the challenging issues brought on by COVID-19." Most of its 13 stores had not reopened after the pandemic arrived. Sales had been rising in early 2020, but the pandemic and the closure of its stores proved too steep a challenge to overcome. Before 2014 the business had included stores and spas aimed at women between 35 and 50. A 2017 count put millennials at 3% of its web sales.

Reports in September 2020 said Newtimes Group had bought the assets for $12.2 million. In August, Newtimes had become the stalking-horse bidder, the first offer that other bids had to beat, with an original price of $8 million. The sale covered intellectual property, inventory, fitting forms and patterns, and the libraries for the brand's catalog. Coldwater Creek and Soft Surroundings were combined in 2023. Today the parent is headquartered in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, and serves women 45 and older. Both brands sell through their own e-commerce sites and catalogs. The parent describes Coldwater Creek as inspired by the natural beauty of the Pacific Northwest.

The brand's tagline is "Inspired by Nature. Designed for You." It now presents itself as shaped by the beauty, artistry and independent spirit of Sandpoint, Idaho.

Between fiscal 2000 and fiscal 2012, catalog circulation dropped from 183.6 million to about 55.6 million, while the store count grew from ten to 349. The company had called its catalogs its most efficient medium for building brand recognition. Direct sales slipped in fiscal 2007, by which time circulation had already fallen to about 129 million. The stated target customer also changed. In 2001 it was women 35 to 55. Today the combined Coldwater Creek and Soft Surroundings parent names women 45 and older.

Coldwater Creek still has a "Request a Catalog" link on its home page. A direct brand thinking about stores can take two checks from its 2007–2014 decline. The first is to track circulation and direct sales as closely as store openings. Between fiscal 2007 and fiscal 2012, direct sales fell from $376.4 million to $168.0 million and retail sales fell from $775.1 million to $574.4 million, while the store count rose from 306 to 349. The second is to know which customer the catalog voice speaks to before spending money to reach a new one.

References

Posts in this series